Between the ‘Religious’ and the ‘Secular’ Attitude. The Conflict Over the Relocation of the Catholic Chapel in the Regional Hospital in Przeworsk

Przemysław Gnyszka

Published: 2018-06-29

Vol. 38 (2017)

Between the ‘Religious’ and the ‘Secular’ Attitude. The Conflict Over the Relocation of the Catholic Chapel in the Regional Hospital in Przeworsk

Przemysław Gnyszka

Abstract

This article analyses the conflict over changing the location of the Catholic chapel in the Regional Hospital in Przeworsk. I conducted in-depth anthropological interviews with people declaring a variety of views on the relocation of the chapel, analysed official documents and materials published in the local press, and reflected on my own observations and experiences in order to define the reasons for the conflict. What measures were taken to prevent the relocation of the chapel and why were these steps chosen? What was the logic behind the specific narratives created by those involved in the dispute and what do they tell us about how these respondents perceive the function of the place of cult within the space of the hospital? To answer these questions I drew upon publications from the field of social anthropology and sociology of religion pertaining to the issues of secularisation, secularity and secularism. Transcending the “traditional” views on secularity and religiosity as separate, nonreducible spheres or “binary opposites”, the choice of literature permits a more careful consideration of the motivation of the actors, their diverse attitude towards the local and Church authorities, and their perception of hospital space and the chapel itself, without disregarding the context of the local politics and history.

Keywords:

secularity, religiosity, Catholicism, hospital, chapel, conflict, Przeworsk, Poland

Download files

PDF

Citation rules

Gnyszka, P. (2018). Between the ‘Religious’ and the ‘Secular’ Attitude. The Conflict Over the Relocation of the Catholic Chapel in the Regional Hospital in Przeworsk. Ethnologia Polona, 38, 71–88. Retrieved from https://journals.iaepan.pl/ethp/article/view/44

Cited by / Share

References

Asad T. 2003. Formations of the Secular. Christianity, Islam, modernity. Stanford.
Brocki M. 2011. Nostalgia za PRL-em. Próba analizy. Polska Sztuka Ludowa Konteksty 1 (292), 26–33.
Bruce S. 2011. Explaining Secularization.InSecularization. In Defence of an Unfashionable Theory. Oxford, 1–56.
Buksiński T. 2011. Publiczne sfery i religie. Poznań, 20–34.
Cannell F. 2010. The Anthropology of Secularism Annual Review of Anthropology 39, 85–100.
Casanova J. 2005. Polska. Od Kościoła narodu do społeczeństwa obywatelskiego. In Religie publiczne w nowoczesnym świecie. Transl. by T. Kunz. Kraków, 159–195.
Casanova J. 2011. The Secular, Secularizations, Secularisms. In M. Jurgensmayeri J. Van Antwerpen (eds.), Rethinking Secularism. Oxford, 57–74.
Durkheim É. 2001. A Definition of the Religious Phenomenon and of Religion. In The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. Transl. by C. Cosman. Oxford–New York, 25–47.
Favret-Saada J. 2016. An anthropology of religious polemics. The case of blasphemy affairs. Hau: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 6 (1), 29–45.
Foucault M. 2003. The Birth of the Clinic. Abingdon.
Habermas J. 2008a. Secularism’s Crisis of Faith: Notes on Post-Secular Society. New perspectives quarterly 25, 17–29.
Habermas J. 2008b. Religion in the Public Sphere In Between Naturalism and Religion: Philosophical Essays. Cambridge MA, 114–149.
Kunysz A. (ed.) 1974. Siedem wieków Przeworska. Szkice, studia i materiały z dziejów miasta. Rzeszów, Przeworsk.
Pelc H. (ed.) 2016. Ósmy wiek Przeworska. Ludzie, obiekty, wydarzenia. Vol. II. Rzeszów.
Staszczak Z. (ed.) 1987. Słownik etnologiczny. Terminy ogólne. Warszawa–Poznań.
Taylor C. 2007. Introduction In A secular age. Cambridge, Massachusetts, London, 1–22.
Internet sources:
Habermas J. 2001. Faith and Knowledge. https://www.friedenspreis-des-deutschen-buchhandels.de/sixcms/media.php/1290/2001%20Acceptance%20Speech%20Juergen%20Habermas.pdf, access: 28.01.2017.
Krakowska V. 2015. Bóg pogroził palcem?. http://supernowosci24.pl/bog-pogrozil-palcem/, access: 28.01.2017.
MT/Radio Maryja 2015. Szpital w Przeworsku chce przenieść kaplicę do piwnicy. http://www.fronda.pl/a/szpital-w-przeworsku-chce-przeniesc-kaplice-do-piwnicy,51496.html, access: 01.02.2017.
Olejarka B. 2015. Zwłoki obok szpitalnej kaplicy. http://supernowosci24.pl/zwloki-obok-szpitalnej-kaplicy/, access: 01.02.2017.
RIRM 2015. SZPITAL W PRZEWORSKU ZA PRZENIESIENIEM KAPLICY Z ODDZIAŁU REHABILITACJI DO PIWNICY. http://www.radiomaryja.pl/informacje/szpital-w-przeworsku-za-przeniesieniem-kaplicy-z-oddzialu-rehabilitacji-do-piwnicy/, access: 01.02.2017.
wż 2015. Kaplica szpitalna zostanie przeniesiona. http://www.jaroslawska.pl/artykul/11597,Kaplica-szpitalna-zostanie-przeniesiona, access: 01.02.2017.
Official documents:
Doc. 1 – The hospital director’s reply to an open letter by the author of the chapel’s interior decoration (Przeworsk, 21.05.2015).
Doc. 2 – A notice regarding the relocation of the hospital chapel put up in the Basilica of the Holy Ghost in Przeworsk. Google Scholar

Przemysław Gnyszka

http://orcid.org/0000-0002-4394-0890

Affiliation:

Institute of Ethnology and Cultural Anthropology - University of Warsaw, Poland

Bio Statement (e.g., department and rank)

B.A. in ethnology at the IECA UW