MINERVA’S OWL FLEES FROM GUNFIRE:: AN AFTER ACTION REPORT FROM A VETERAN OF THE SCHOLARLY WARS ABOUT EX-YUGOSLAVIA

Robert Hayden

doi:10.23858/ethp.2023.44.3387

Published: 2023-12-19

Vol. 44 (2023)

MINERVA’S OWL FLEES FROM GUNFIRE:

Robert Hayden

Ethnologia Polona

Section: Main topic of the issue

https://doi.org/10.23858/ethp.2023.44.3387

Abstract

Anthropologists who do research in regions in which armed conflict breaks out between ethnic or religious-heritage communities are often called upon to give opinions on the events there. When such a conflict becomes the subject of international moral discourses, the pressure on scholars to conform to dominant positions is acute, and can lead to analyses that are not well grounded in what can be reasonably understood as facts on the ground, but that adhere to moralizing discourses that not only favour one side over another, but that depict as illegitimate, and often immoral, discussions that do anything more than condemn the other side. In the 1990s, the wars in ex-Yugoslavia led to conflicts between scholars that were too often phrased as ad hominem moral disqualifications of those taking unpopular positions, even when the latter’s views were well grounded in what could be learned about the conflict. This article is a reflection by a veteran of such ad hominem attacks by scholars whose concerns were not with the accuracy of the writings they attacked, but rather with whether the positions assailed were supposedly in conflict with moral(ising) stances. The issues are not new, or unique to the conflicts in ex-Yugoslavia, so perhaps this personal account can be of some relevance to others who may face similar issues.

Download files

PDF

Citation rules

Hayden, R. (2023). MINERVA’S OWL FLEES FROM GUNFIRE:: AN AFTER ACTION REPORT FROM A VETERAN OF THE SCHOLARLY WARS ABOUT EX-YUGOSLAVIA. Ethnologia Polona, 44. https://doi.org/10.23858/ethp.2023.44.3387

Cited by / Share

Licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

References

Boas, Franz. [1919] 2005. “Scientists as Spies.” Anthropology Today 21 (3): 27. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.0268-540X.2005.00359 (accessed 18.01.2023)
Google Scholar

Bougarel, Xavier. 1996a. “Bosnia and Herzegovina — State and Communitarianism.” In Yugoslavia and After, edited by David A. Dyker and Ivan Vejvoda, 87-115. London: Longman.
Google Scholar

Bougarel, Xavier. 1996b. Bosnie, anatomie d’un conflit. Les Dossiers de l’Etat du monde. Paris: La Découverte.
Google Scholar

Burg, Steven L., and Paul Shoup. 1999. The war in Bosnia-Herzegovina: ethnic conflict and international intervention. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe.
Google Scholar

Central Intelligence Agency. 2002. Balkan Battlegrounds, Vol. 1. Washington, DC: Central Intelligence Agency.
Google Scholar

Denich, Bette. 2005. “Debate or Defamation?” Anthropological Theory 5 (4): 555–558.
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 1990. Social Courts in Theory and Practice: Yugoslav Workers’ Courts in Comparative Perspective. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 1996. “Imagined Communities and Real Victims: Self-Determination and Ethnic Cleansing in Yugoslavia.” American Ethnologist 23 (4): 783–801. http://www.jstor.org/stable/646183
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 1999a. Blueprints for a House Divided: The Constitutional Logic of the Yugoslav Conflicts. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 1999b. “Humanitarian Hypocrisy.” East European Constitutional Review 8 (3): 91–96.
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 2000. “Biased ‘Justice’: Humanrightsism and the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia.” Cleveland State Law Review 47: 549–573.
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 2007. “Moral Vision and Impaired Insight: The Imagining of Other Peoples’ Communities in Bosnia.” Current Anthropology 48 (1): 105–131.
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 2011. “Wha’s Reconciliation Got to Do with It? The ICTY as Antiwar Profiteer.” Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 5 (3): 313–330.
Google Scholar

Hayden, Robert M. 2013. From Yugoslavia to the Western Balkans: Studies in a EuropeanDisunion, 1991-2011. Leiden: Brill.
Google Scholar

Jefferson, Thomas. [1809] 1984. “‘The Republic of Science’ — letter to John Hollins.” In Thomas Jefferson: Writings, edited by Merrill D. Peterson, 1200-1202. New York: Literary Classics of the United States.
Google Scholar

Keynes, John Maynard. [1920] 2019. The Economic Consequences of the Peace. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Google Scholar

Kušić, Katarina, Polina Manolova, and Phillip Lottholz, eds. 2019. Decolonial theory & practice in Southeast Europe. Sofia: dVersia/ dБерсия.
Google Scholar

Lyon, James. 1995. “Yugoslavia’s Hyperinflation 1993-1994: The Winter of Discontent.” Godišnjak za društvenu istoriju 2 (1): 89–103.
Google Scholar

Mann, Michael. 2005. The Dark Side of Democracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Google Scholar

Peacock, James, Robert Albro, Carolyn Fluehr-Lobban, Kerry Fosher, Laura McNamara, Monica Heller, George Marcus, and David Price. 2007. Final Report of the AAA Commission on the Engagement of Anthropology with the U.S. Security and Intelligence Communities. Washington DC: American Anthropological Association.
Google Scholar

Petrakou, Eleni. 2023. “Splitting the atomic scientists: how the Ukraine war ruined physics.” The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/jan/15/scientists-ukraine-war-cern-physics-large-hadron-collider (accessed Janaury 18 2023)
Google Scholar

Ramet, Sabrina. 2005. Thinking about Yugoslavia: Scholarly Debates about the Yugoslav Breakup and the Wars in Bosnia and Kosovo. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Google Scholar

Rusinow, Dennison I. 1977. The Yugoslav experiment, 1948-1974. London: C. Hurst for the Royal Institute of International Affairs.
Google Scholar

Stubbs, Paul. 2013. “Flex Actors and Philanthropy in (Post-)Conflict Arenas: Soros’ Open Society Foundations in the Post-Yugoslav Space.” Politička misao: Croatian political science review 50 (5): 114–138.
Google Scholar

Todorov, Tzvetan. 1996. Facing the Extreme: Moral Life in the Concentration Camps. New York: Metropolitan Books.
Google Scholar

Weber, Max. 2020. Charisma and Disenchanment: The Vocation Lectures. Translated by Damion Searls. edited by Paul Reitter and Chad Wellmon. New York, NY: New York Review of Books.
Google Scholar

Woodward, Susan. 1995. Balkan Tragedy: Chaos and Dissolution after the Cold War. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
Google Scholar