Early Bronze Age Pamukli bair barrow near Malomirovo and the problem of east-oriented barrow graves in Upper Thrace
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.23858/SA/75.2023.1.3558Keywords:
barrows, Early Bronze Age, Upper Thrace, absolute chronology, funeral riteAbstract
In 2021, excavations of a barrow were conducted on the Pamukli Bair hill in Malomirovo, Elhovo municipality, Upper Thrace, Bulgaria. These excavations yielded a remarkable discovery – a sequence of graves dating back to the late fourth and third millennium BC. Notably, these findings prominently featured elements of the early Pit-Grave culture, also known as the Yamna culture. However, the commencement of this burial sequence was marked by graves that diverged from the norms of the Yamna culture. These early graves contained individuals interred in a crouched position, with their heads oriented towards the east. Unlike the prevalent use of ochre in the Yamna culture, this type of funeral ritual exhibited a limited presence of ochre. Comparable central graves of this kind have also been documented in other barrows throughout the Middle Tundzha region and various parts of Upper Thrace, particularly in the “Maritsa-Iztok” area. These burials can be dated to the end of the fourth millennium BC and display similarities to both local funeral traditions (Ezero A1) and graves analogous to the Cernavodă/Nizhna Mikhailivka traditions. The horizon of barrow necropolises featuring these distinctive burials is clearly discernible within the Upper Thrace region and seamlessly connects to the horizon of the early Pit-Grave culture.
Downloads
References
Agre 2007. Arheologicheski razkopki na nadgrobna mogila v zemlishteto na s. Popovo, obshtina Bolyarovo, Yambolska oblast. In K. Vagalinski (ed.), Arheologicheski otkritia i razkopki prez 2006 g. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 74-75.
Agre D. 2011. The tumulus of Golyamata Mogila near the villages of Malomirovo and Zlatinitsa. Sofia: Avalon, 2011.
Agre D. 2015. Archaeological investigation of the “Lozianska Mogila” barrow located near the Village of Boyanovo, Municipality of Elkhovo, South-eastern Bulgaria. Prahistorische Zeitschrift 90/1-2, 141-171. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/pz-2015-0003
Agre D. and Dichev D. 2013. Arheologicheski razkopki na mogila № 1 „Sechenata mogila“ v zemlishteto na s. Sinapovo, obshtina Topolovgrad. In L. Vagalinski (ed.), Arheologicheski otkritiya i razkopki prez 2012 g. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 122-125.
Alexandrov S. 2010. Prehistoric barrow graves with extended inhumations between the Danube and the Balkan Range. Studia Praehistorica 13, 277-292.
Alexandrov S. 2011. Prehistoric barrow graves between Danube and Balkan range: stratigraphy and relative chronology.In E. Borgna and S. Muller Celka (eds), Ancestral Landscapes. Burial Mounds in the Copper and Bronze Ages (Central and Eastern Europe – Balkans – Adriatic – Aegean, 4th – 2nd millennium B.C.) (= Travaux de la Maison de l’Orient 58) Lyon: Maison de l’Orient et de la Méditerranée, 307-320.
Alexandrov S. 2018. Early Bronze Age tumular grave near Troyanovo, Radnevo region. In S. Alexandrov, Y. Dimitrova, H. Popov, B. Horejs and K. Chukalev (eds), Gold and bronze: Metals, technologies and interregional contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 323-324.
Alexandrov S. 2020. Bronze Age barrow graves in Upper Thrace: Old and new questions. In S. Hansen (ed.), Reprasentationen der Macht. Beitrage des Festkolloquiums zu Ehren des 65. Geburtstags von Blagoje Govedarica (= Kolloquien zur Vor- und Fruhgeschichte 25) Wiesbaden: Harrasowitz, 147-170.
Alexandrov S., Galabova B. and Atanasova-Timeva N. 2016. Spasitelni arheologicheski prouchvaniya na nadgrobna mogila № 5, zemlishte na s. Beli briag, obshtina Radnevo. In L. Vagalinski (ed.), Arheologicheski otkritiya i razkopki prez 2015 g. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 153-154.
Alexandrov S. and Kaiser E. 2016. The early barrow graves in West Pontic Area. Cultures? Migrations? Interactions? In V. Nikolov and W. Schier (eds), Der Schwarzmeerraum vom Neolithikum bis in die Fruheisenzeit (6000-600 v. Chr.). Kulturelle Interferenzen in der Zirkumpontischen Zone und Kontakte mit ihren Nachbargebieten. Humboldt-Kolleg Varna, Bulgarien, 16-20. Mai 2012 (= Prahistorische Archäologie in Südosteuropa 29). Rahden/Westf.: Leidorf, 351-362.
Alexandrov S. and Kirov I. 2017. Spasitelni arheologicheski prouchvaniya na nadgrobna „Kangalova” mogila ot rannata bronzova epoha, zemilshche na s. Troyanovo, obshtina Radnevo. In L. Vagalinski (ed.), Arheologicheski otkritiya i razkopki prez 2016. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 126-127.
Alexandrov S. and Iliev I. 2016. Spasitelni arheologicheski prouchvaniya na nadgrobna mogila (obekt no. 6 po traseto na tranziten gazoprovod za Turtsiya), zemlishte na grad Straldzha, obshtina Straldzha. In L. Vagalinski (ed.), Arheologicheski otkritiya i razkopki prez 2015 g. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 113-114.
Alexandrov S., Dimitrova Y., Popov H., Horejs B. and Chukalev K. eds 2018. Gold and bronze: Metals, technologies and interregional contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: Blgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arkheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 2018.
Alexandrov S., Vasileva E. and Iliev I. 2023. Spasitelni arheologicheski prouchvaniya na nadgrobna mogila v zemlishteto na s. Zimnitsa, oblast Yambol (AM „Trakiya”, LOT 4, obekt No. 14A – razkopki 2009 g.). In S Alexandrov and T. Stefanova (eds), Spasitelni arheologicheski prouchvaniya po traseto na AM „Trakia” LOT 3-5. Sofia 2023 (in print)
Alexandrov S. and Włodarczak P. 2022. Chronological sequence of the Early Bronze Age graves in the Pamukli Bair Barrow at Malomirovo and the Pit-Grave Culture expansion in the Middle Tundzha Valley. Studia Praehistorica 16, 207-240.
Anthony D. W. 2009. The horse, the wheel and language. How Bronze-age riders from the Eurasian steppes shaped the modern world. Princeton-Oxford: Princeton Univeristy Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400831104
Batsova E. and Kanchev M. 1974. Novootkriti trakiyski pogrebeniya v Novozagorsko. Arheologiya H1, 50-57.
Boyadzhiev Y., Andonova A., Petrov V. and Boyadzhiev K. 2015. Obekt „Chavdarova cheshma“, Simeonovgrad. In L. Vagalinski (ed.), Arheologicheski otkritiya i razkopki prez 2014 g. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 70-73.
Buyukliev H. 1964. Dve rannotrakiyski mogilni pogrebeniya ot Starozagorsko. Arheologiya 4, 63-65.
Dimitrova D. 2014. Grobove ot bronzovata epoha pri Kamen, Slivensko. Arheologiya H1-2, 69-82.
Dimitrova D. 2021. Grobove ot rannata bronzova epoha v Gabrova mogila. In D. Georgeva (ed.), Sbornik v pamet na Rumen Katincharov (= Izvestiya na Natsionalniya Arheologicheski Institut 47). Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 191-202.
Gleser R. and Thomas T. 2012. Drama. Forschungen in einer Mikroregion, Band 1. Merdžumekja-Südosthang. Spät Kupferzeit und früheste Bronzezeit: Ergebnisse siedlungsarchäologischer Forschungen. Bonn: Verlag Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH.
Heyd V. 2011. Yamnaya groups and tumuli west of the Black Sea. In E. Borgna and Muller Celka (eds), Ancestral Landscapes. Burial Mounds in the Copper and Bronze Ages (Central and Eastern Europe – Balkans – Adriatic – Aegean, 4th-2nd millennium B.C.) (= Travaux de la Maison de l’Orient 58) Lyon: Maison de l’Orient et de la Méditerranée, 535-555.
Hristov M., Panayotova K., Gurova M., Panayotov I. and Mikov R. 2023. Spasitelni arhyeologicheski prouchvaniya na obekt № 16, km 195+300 – 195+600, LOT 1, AM „Trakiya“ (predvaritelni nabliudeniya). In S. Alexandrov and T. Stefanova (eds), Spasitelni arheologicheski prouchvaniya po traseto na AM „Trakia” LOT 3-5. Sofia (in print)
Hristova R. 2009. Materiali ot rannata i kasnata bronzova epoha pri prouchvane na traseto na AM „Trakiya“, LOT 5, km 6+700 – 6+800. In D. Momchilov and R. Georgieva (eds), Spasitelni arheologicheski prouchvaniya po traseto na AM „Trakiya“, LOT 5, obhoden pat na grad Karnobat, km 6+400 – 6+800. Varna: Zograf, 33-49.
Hristova T. and Uzunov Z. 2012. Kolektiven grob s trupopolagane ot rannata bronzova epoha pri Sabrano, Novozagorsko. Arheologiya 53/1, 62-67.
Iliev I. 2011. The Pit Grave culture in the lower Tundzha valley. Studia Praehistorica 14, 381-398.
Iliev I. and Bakardžiev S. 2020. Kurgane der frühen bis späten Bronzezeit im Bezirk Jambol, Südostbulgarien (= Yamnaya Impact on Prehistoric Europe 1). Budapest: Archaeolingua.
Iliev S. 2018. Tumulus from the Early Bronze Age near the town of Merichleri, Southeast ulgaria. In S. Alexandrov, Y. Dimitrova, H. Popov, B. Horejs and K. Chukalev (eds), Gold and bronze: Metals, technologies and interregional contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey, 318-322.
Ivanova S., Petrenko V. and Vetchinnikova N. 2005. Kurgany drevikh skotovodov mezhdurechia Yuzhnogo Buga i Dnestra. Odessa: Institut Arkheologii Natsionalnoy Akademii Nauk Ukrainy.
Kaiser E. and Winger K. 2015. Pit graves in Bulgaria and the Yamnaya Culture. Prähistorische Zeitschrift 90/1-2, 114-140. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/pz-2015-0001
Kanchev M. 1991. Nekropoli ot bronzovata epoha v rayona na Maritsa-iztok. In I. Panayotov, K. Leshchakov, R. Georgieva, S. Alexandrov and B. Borisov (eds), „Maritsa-iztok” Arheologicheski prouchvaniya 1. Radnevo: Ekspeditsiya „Maritsa-iztok”, 41-70.
Kanchev M. 1995. Nadgrobna mogila II (Golyamata mogila) do selo Golyama Detelina, obshchina Radnevo (chast I). In I. Panayotov, R. Georgieva, K. Leshchakov, S. Alexandrov and B. Borisov (eds), „Maritsa-iztok” Arheologicheski prouchvaniya 3. Radnevo: Arheologicheski muzey „Maritsaiztok” – gr. Radnevo, Arheologicheska ekspeditsiya „Maritsa-iztok”, 35-63.
Kancheva-Ruseva T. 1994. Yamni pogrebeniya v mogila II ot mogilniya nekropol v zemlishcheto na s. Pet mogili, Novozagorsko. In S. Alexandrov and B. Borisov (eds), „Maritsa-iztok” Arheologicheski prouchvaniya 2. Radnevo-Nova Zagora: Arheologicheski muzey „Maritsa-iztok”-Obshchinski svet, 91-94.
Krauss R., Tsirtsoni Z., Maniatis Y., Oberlin C., Pernicka E. and Leshtakov P. 2020. Absolute Chronology of the Excavated Features at Akladi Cheiri and the Beginning of Copper Metallurgy in the Eastern Balkans. In R. Krauss, E. Pernicka, R. Kunze, K. Dimitrov and P. Leshtakov (eds), Prehistoric mining and metallurgy at the Southeast Bulgarian Black Sea coast (= Ressourcen Kulturen Band 12). Tübingen: Tübingen University Press, 177-184.
Lazaridis I., Alpaslan-Roodenberg S., Acar A., Açikkol A., Agelarakis A., Aghikyan L. et al. 2022. The genetic history of the Southern Arc: A bridge between West Asia and Europe. Science, 377(6609), doi/10.1126/science.abm4247.
Leshchakov K. 2006. Bronzovata epoha v Gornotrakiyskata nizina. Godishnik na Sofiyskia Universitet, Istoricheski fakultet 3 (2002), 141-216.
Leshchakov K. and Borisov B. 1995. Nadgrobna mogila IV ot rannata bronzova epoha v zemlishcheto na selo Golyama Detelina, obshchina Radnevo. In I. Panayotov, R. Georgieva, K. Leshchakov, S. Alexandrov and B. Borisov (eds), „Maritsa-iztok” Arheologicheski prouchvaniya 3. Radnevo: Arheologicheski muzey „Maritsa-iztok” – gr. Radnevo, Arheologicheska ekspeditsiya „Maritsa-Iztok”, 9-33.
Leshchakov K. and Popova Ts. 1995. Nadgrobna mogila II (Golyamata mogila) do selo Golyama Detelina, obchtina Radnevo (vtora chast). In I. Panayotov, R. Georgieva, K. Leshchakov, S. Alexandrov and B. Borisov (eds), „Maritsa-iztok” Arheologicheski prouchvaniya 3. Radnevo: Arheologicheski muzey „Maritsa-iztok” – gr. Radnevo, Arheologicheska ekspeditsiya „Maritsa-Iztok”, 63-86.
Leshtakov K., Kancheva-Russeva T. and Stoyanov S. 2001. Prehistoric studies. Settlement sites. In I. Panayotov et al. (eds), Maritsa-Iztok. Archaeological Research 5. Radnevo, 15-68.
Leshtakov P., Klasnakov M., Samichkova G. and K. McSweeney 2020. The Prehistoric Site Akladi Cheiri, Chernomorets. In R. Krauss, E. Pernicka, R. Kunze, K. Dimitrov and P. Leshtakov (eds), Prehistoric mining and metallurgy at the Southeast Bulgarian Black Sea coast (= Ressourcen Kulturen 12). Tübingen: Tübingen University Press, 89-120.
Manzura I. 2003-2004. Severnoe Prichernomorie v eneolite i bronzovom veke: stepeni kolonizatsii. Stratum plus 2, 63-85.
Manzura I. 2013. Kultury stepnogo eneolita. In: I. V. Bruyako and T. L. Samoylova (eds), Drevnie kultury severo-zapadnogo Prichernomoria. Odessa: Odesskiy arkheologicheskiy muzey Natsionalnoy akademii nauk Ukrainy, 115-153.
Mathieson I., Alpaslan-Roodenberg S., Posth C., Szécsényi-Nagy A., Rohland N., Mallick S. et al. 2018. The genomic history of southeastern Europe. Nature 555(7695), 197-203. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature25778
Minkov P. 2021. Askoi from the Early Bronze Age in the burial contexts from the present-day Bulgarian lands (observations on relative chronology, characteristics and volume data). Proceedings of the National Museum of History 33, 92-120.
Nikolov V. and Petrova V. 2016. Tell Karanovo: the hiatus between the Late Copper and the Early Bronze Age. In Z. Tsirtsoni (ed.), The Human Face of Radiocarbon. Reassessing chronology in DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/books.momeditions.512
prehistoric Greece and Bulgaria, 5000-3000 calBC (= Travaux de la Maison de L’orient et de la Méditerranée, 69). Lyon: Maison de l’Orient et de la Méditerranée, 127-141.
Nikolova L. 2000. Yamnaya kultura na Balkanakh. Stratum plus 2, 423-458.
Panayotov I. 1989. Yamnata kultura v Balgarskite zemi. Razkopki i prouchvania 21. Sofia: Balgarska Akademiya na Naukite, Natsionalen Arheologicheski Institut s Muzey.
Panayotov and Alexandrov 1995. Mogilen nekropol ot rannata bronzova epoha v zemlishtata na selata Mednikarovo i Iskritsa. In I. Panayotov, R. Georgieva, K. Leshchakov, S. Alexandrov and B. Borisov (eds), „Maritsa-iztok” Arheologicheski prouchvaniya 3. Radnevo: Arheologicheski muzey „Maritsa-iztok” – gr. Radnevo, Arheologicheska ekspeditsiya „Maritsa-iztok”, 87-113.
Penske S., Rohrlach A. B., Childebayeva A., Gnecchi-Ruscone G., Schmid C., Spyrou M. A., Neumann G. U., Atanassova N., Beutler K., Boyadzhiev K., Boyadzhiev Y., Bruyako I., Chohadzhiev A., Govedarica B., Karaucak M., Krauss R., Leppek M., Manzura I., Privat K., Ross S., Slavchev V., Sobotkova A., Toderaş M., Valchev T., Ringbauer H., Stockhammer P. W., Hansen S., Krause J. and Haak W. 2023. Early contact between late farming and pastoralist societies in southeastern Europe. Nature 620, 358-365. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-06334-8
Preda-Bălănică B. E. and Diekmann Y. 2022. Ancestry and identity in the Balkans and the Carpathian basin between the 5th and 3rd millennia cal BC. In A. Whittle, J. Pollard and S. Geaney (eds), Ancient DNA and the European Neolithic: Relations and Descent (= Neolithic Studies Group Seminar Papers 19). Oxford and Philadelphia: Oxbow Books, 107-122. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/jj.2775905.13
Rassamakin Yu. 1999. The Eneolithic of the Black Sea Steppe: Dynamics of Cultural and Economic Development 4500-2300 BC. In M. Levine, Yu. Rassamakin, A. Kislenko and N. Tatarintseva (eds), Late prehistoric exploitation of the Eurasian steppes. Cambridge: Oxbow Books, 59-182.
Rassamakin Yu. 2013. From the late Eneolithic Period to the Early Bronze Age in the Black Sea Steppe: What is the Pit Grave Culture (Late Fourth to Mid-Third Millenium BC)? In V. Heyd, G. Kulcsár and V. Szeverényi (eds), Transition to the Bronze Age. Interregional Interaction and Socio-Cultural Change in the Third Millenium BC. Carpathian Basin and Neighbouring Regions, Budapest: Archaeolingua, 113-138.
Stefan C. E., Vasile G., Petcu R., Heroiu A., Preda-Bălănică B. and Trautmann M. 2023. The Bronze Age mounds from Aliman (Constanţa County, Romania). In B. Preda-Bălănică and M. Ahola (eds), Steppe transmissions (= Yamnaya Impact on Prehistoric Europe 4). Budapest: Achaeolingua, 95-133.
Włodarczak P. 2020. Sequence of graves in barrows 4th-3rd millennium BC in the Danube-Tisza region. Pontica 53, 135-155.
Włodarczak P. 2021. Eneolithic and Early Bronze Age barrows in Vojvodina. In: P. Jarosz, J. Koledin and P. Włodarczak (red.), Danubian Route of the Yamnaya Culture. The barrows of Vojvodina (= The Yamnaya Impact on Prehistoric Europe 3). Budapest: Archaeolingua, 215-255.
Włodarczak P., Manova R., Podsiadło M., Trautmann M. and Alexandrov S. 2023. The old man and the three babi. An exceptional burial from the Pamukli Bair barrow near Malomirovo, Southeast Bulgaria. In A. Lahelma, M. Lavento, K. Mannermaa, M. Ahola, E. Holmqvist and K. Nordqvist (eds), Moving northward. Professor Volker Heyd’s Festschrift as he turns 60 (= Monographs of the Archaeological Society of Finland 11). Helsinki: Archaeological Society of Finland, 34-49.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Sprawozdania Archeologiczne
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
